Toasted Pickle

The Toasted Pickle is a one of a kind sandwich shop in the heart of downtown Grand Haven, Michigan. Stop by for lunch or dinner for a truly unique lineup of hand-crafted sandwiches, salads and soups. Featuring fresh, local ingredients, the Pickle serves up a new twist on some traditional sandwiches – including the Crusty Cuban, Monte Cristo and Billy From Philly.

The house-made theme carries throughout the menu – salads are served with house-made dressings and the soups are all from scratch. Not to be missed are the award-winning Pickle Poppers served with Kick’n Pickle sauce and the Parmesan truffle fries with a side of our own pimento cheese sauce. A visit to the Pickle is not complete without trying one of the hand-squeezed lemonades available in a dozen flavors and infused with fresh fruit and herbs.

Their Story

In the early days of the industrial revolution, a secret society of sandwich artisans existed. It was known as The Order of The Toasted Pickle. This was a group of ambitious and daring rebels who pushed their craft, developing distinct twists on classic sandwich recipes. Tragically, with the advent of the microwave, their recipes were lost in a whirlwind of processed pandemonium.

But now, after all these years, our dedicated culinary craftsmen have unearthed their eclectic mix of edible oddities and savory classics for everyone to enjoy. This isn’t just another “sandwich shop”. No sireee… This is an experience that will put a smile on your face, a hop in your step, and a tingle on your tongue—always served with a pickle on the side! Because as Papa Zeke always used to say, “If you ever find yourself in a pickle, eat your way out.”